Showing posts with label crowdfunding. Show all posts
Showing posts with label crowdfunding. Show all posts

Friday, July 24, 2026

June 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

It's still July, so this isn't yet completely 100% late. That's a win in my book, so check out the raw data and dive in.

June 2026 featured:

  • 138 campaigns
    • 43 Backerkit
    • 4 Gamefound
    • 91 Kickstarter
  • $22,674,684.93 raised
    • $2,795,372.59 on Backerkit
    • $819,218.51 on Gamefound
    • $19,060,093.83 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 11 accessories
    • 43 adventures
    • 1 advice
    • 1 audiobook
    • 10 campaign settings
    • 1 magazine
    • 2 platforms
    • 45 supplements
    • 22 systems
    • 2 VTT modules
  • 56 distinct systems used (12 original)
    • 47 campaigns (34.06%) used D&D 5E and raised $17,623,942.28 (77.73% of all money raised in June)
  • 39 campaigns used AI in some form (24.23% of total) and raised $312,129.73 (1.38% of all money raised in June)
    • 29 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 61.70% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 16 different countries
    • Top 3: 70 in USA, 21 in UK, 10 in Italy
    • Singleton countries: Cyprus, Greece, New Zealand, Norway, Spain

Backerkit's June

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in June were:

  1. Outgunned Adventure: Broken Compass Legacy by Two Little Mice ($477,159.25 from 2,939 backers)
  2. Amsel Suite – Chapter II by Ollam Technologies ($460,996.74 from 3,652 backers)
  3. Old-School Essentials Demonic Grimoire by Exalted Funeral ($445,565 from 5,430 backers)
  4. Night Shift: Devil Division by Slightly Reckless Games ($361,793.83 from 2,229 backers)
  5. Memory Core by Horrible Guild ($236,283.28 from 1,430 backers)

Gamefound's June

The 4 campaigns on Gamefound in June were:

  1. Archvillain Encounters: Death & Beyond from Archvillain Games ($815,781.67 from 2,321 backers)
  2. Pogromcy by Dungal Games ($2,131.79 from 35 backers)
  3. Deep Sky Ballad - For a Fistful of Seeds by Winged Lion Games ($707.42 from 25 backers)
  4. Nephilion: Der Diplomat (Missionsband) by Nephilion ($597.63 from 8 backers)

Kickstarter's June

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in June were:

  1. Neon Odyssey: Space Opera in D&D by Legends of Avantris by Legends of Avantris ($16,138,971 from 49,115 backers)
  2. Tom Clancy's The Division, the official tabletop RPG by Arkhane Asylum Publishing ($705,191 from 2,787 backers)
  3. Symbaroum RPG – Revised Core Books & Setting Expansion by Free League ($595,115.18 from 2,855 backers)
  4. The Book of Unnumbered Worlds by Kevin Crawford ($208,660 from 3,444 backers)
  5. City of Sirens: 5E+ Urban Adventures in the Eldritch Fallout by Quill's Tiny Quests ($201,406 from 1,647 backers)

June 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026

2024 2025 2026
Campaign count
Backerkit 20 21 43
Kickstarter 139 131 91
Money pledged
Backerkit total $1,411,365.07 $3,243,137.69 $2,795,372.59
Backerkit average $70,568.25 $154,435.13 $65,008.66
Backerkit median $20,097.50 $14,539.00 $8,294.00
Kickstarter total $3,786,692.31 $4,533,617.87 $19,060,093.83
Kickstarter average $27,242.39 $34,607.77 $209,451.58
Kickstarter median $3,721.00 $2,931.00 $5,186.00
AI
Campaign count 34 41 38
Money pledged $215,853.36 $544,766.14 $311,532.10
D&D 5E
Campaign count 69 65 47
Money pledged $1,893,054.82 $2,717,489.68 $17,623,942.28

I don't have much to say about June's data due to a general listlessness caused by a variety of personal reasons (which is also why this is coming so late), but something that is interesting is a certain trend toward stabilization that I've been seeing the last few months. When I started comparing the last three years' data back in November, it really looked like there was an overall increase in crowdfunding across the board in terms of the number of successful campaigns and money pledged across both Backerkit and Kickstarter. Now, though, it's starting to level off. Backerkit projects are increasing in number while Kickstarters are decreasing, and the money is staying relatively stable (if on a slight increase likely due to inflation and increases in production costs, which are then reflected in pledge tier pricing). It's only when you have projects from creators like Legends of Avantris, who bring a potentially new audience into the space, that you see big spikes in money raised.

This pattern has repeated itself across the time I've been tracking these data: Draw Steel (at the time MCDM RPG), the Cosmere RPG, the Discworld RPG, the Magnus Archives RPG, the new edition of the Alien RPG. (Avatar Legends TTRPG also applies here obviously but I wasn't yet tracking data.) Most really notable projects (in terms of money raised) are not just activating TTRPG fans already on crowdfunding platforms but notifying existing fans of how they can get more of what they already like. (One could argue that D&D itself operates much the same way despite crowdfunding campaigns not actually being run by WotC.) These properties/companies also have the resources to promise and deliver on whale tiers full of bells and whistles, buy Facebook ads to reach people who otherwise might not frequent crowdfunding websites, and pay for splashy art to adorn the crowdfunding page prior to actually collecting any funds for the project.

To be clear, none of this is exactly criticism of these practices or the people who do them. I'm by no means happy about a piece of art's success being dependent on marketing and existing capital, but that's hardly something unique to the TTRPG space. My larger point is rather that time and time again, I am reminded of the reality that >50% of crowdfunding projects raise at most ~$8000 (and more regularly ~$5000 at most), and that that number has stayed incredibly consistent over the last 3.5 years. It would be foolish of me to suggest that we're reaching a carrying capacity in TTRPG crowdfunding (as I am well aware that biologists are notoriously bad at predicting any ecosystem's carrying capacity), but I'm definitely seeing growth slowing down.

Monday, June 15, 2026

May 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

 

Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

I think we might have finally done it: we've reached the end of Backerkit's themed Months with the end of OSE Month. Or at least, we've reached the end of them for now. I'm not plugged in to the Mothership or Mausritter communities, but now would be the time for them to start planning for their respective Months in November/December if they're happening...

Anyways, here's May's raw data. Let's dive in!

  • 194 campaigns
    • 71 Backerkit
    • 5 Gamefound
    • 118 Kickstarter
  • $21,498,324.43 raised
    • $17,186,480.54 on Backerkit
    • $235,153.86 on Gamefound
    • $4,076,690.03 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 17 accessories
    • 1 Actual Play
    • 64 adventures
    • 10 campaign settings
    • 1 fundraising
    • 2 magazines
    • 1 platform
    • 1 reprint
    • 49 supplements
    • 47 systems
    • 1 translation
  • 75 distinct systems used (31 original)
    • 81 campaigns (41.75%) used D&D 5E and raised $3,837,448.45 (17.85% of all money raised in May)
  • 47 campaigns used AI in some form (24.23% of total) and raised $799,428.25 (3.72% of all money raised in May)
    • 31 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 38.27% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 17 different countries
    • Top 3: 103 in USA, 23 in UK, 13 in Italy
    • Singleton countries: Argentina, Ireland, Japan, Norway, Portugal, Switzerland

Backerkit's May

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in May were:
  1. Dungeon Crawler Carl RPG + Unstoppable by Renegade Game Studios ($13,298,059 from 55,972 backers)
  2. Traveller 5e by World's Largest RPGs ($841,443 from 2,374 backers)
  3. Gary Gygax's Castle Dungeons! by Troll Lord Games ($582,174 from 2,682 backers)
  4. Castle Whiterock by Goodman Games ($571,286 from 4,078 backers)
  5. Jewel in the Sky: A Megadungeon with a Twist from Monte Cook by Monte Cook Games ($302,132 from 2,674 backers)
Although DCCarl was not actually part of Megadungeon Month, it is somewhat fitting that it coincided with it considering that it is, at least aesthetically, set inside a megadungeon. You could certainly quibble as to how closely it corresponds given that there is no revisiting of levels after clearing them, but I don't think anyone actually cares about that. I do only know this because I have now had the mild misfortune of reading the first two books in the series, and these are my main takeaways:
  1. Dungeon Crawler Carl is a shockingly poorly written series of books, filled with only slightly less than egregious racial stereotypes. I find it compelling for the same reason police procedurals are compelling (I love a problem being solved in front of my eyes), despite having many of the same fundamental and aesthetic problems as said police procedurals.
  2. It makes complete sense that the 'game' described in the books would make over $13M. In many ways, my many issues raised above may actually contribute to its success given that the same criticisms could be leveled at Dungeons & Dragons (& descendants).
Do I think that the game (which I did not back) will be able to live up to the promises made by the books? Eh, yes and know. The style of the books is an intoxicating mix of "RAWR XD so random" + World of Warcraft fantasy aesthetics + mid-2010s Reddit (including the most basic critique of corporate capitalism), and I don't know how easily people who are not Matt Dinniman will be able (or want) to replicate that particular sludge of inspirations. Ultimately, it's probably a more honest representation of how a lot of people already play D&D, even if they think they're playing Critical Role at home.

Gamefound's May

The top (and only) 5 campaigns on Gamefound in May were:
  1. Last Arc: Tactics Analogue by Succubus Publishing ($200,109.70 from 1,503 backers)
  2. Pathfinder 2 - Rache der Runenherrscher by Ulisses Spiele ($34,455.35 from 258 backers)
  3. Shadows of the 1930s: 450+ RPG Battle Maps by Agnesagraphic ($375.53 from 14 backers)
  4. BITTER HARVEST: 80 Cursed Elixirs: A 5e Dark Mediterranean Compendium of Potions, Penance, and Power by Oranges and Olives ($160.54 from 15 backers)
  5. 1200+ POST-APOCALYPTIC BATTLE MAPS - INVASION FROM HELL by Agnesagraphic ($52.74 from 1 backer)
Gamefound continues to baffle me with its feast and famine patterns of funding. Either you have fairly successful (often $100K+) projects that don't seem to have a presence anywhere else that I'm online, or you have less than a handful of mildly funded projects that may or may not double dip with a Kickstarter. The things that tend to do the best are the most board game-shaped objects (like Last Arc: Tactics Analogue, which has a fair number of physical components to add on, though surprisingly no minis), which tracks for the overall focus of Gamefound as a platform. I'll be watching their next RPG Party closely to see how sustainable it all is and how much attention/creators it can attract from its competitor platforms.

Kickstarter's May

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in May were:
  1. The PackMule Ultimate 5E Inventory System by Eternal_GM ($616,278 from 2,031 backers)
  2. Historia Arcanum: The Coven of Salem by Metis Creative ($550,252 from 3,164 backers)
  3. Realis by Tyler Crumrine ($354,529 from 7,359 backers)
  4. Zoologist's Primer: Birds by Hunters Books ($344,454 from 3,710 backers)
  5. Tabletop Table: The Portable, Modular Gaming Table is Back by Tabletop Table ($227,563 from 368 backers)
It's finally happened: the most successful Kickstarter campaign in a month used AI. Specifically, AI was used for "early concept exploration for simpler item-image ideas and for some internal drafting/template assistance related to flavor-text workflow," whatever that means. Now keep in mind that this product, the PackMule Ultimate 5E Inventory System, is literally just making physical cards for every item in the D&D 5E SRD. And therein lies the problem, I think. They obviously cannot use the art that exists for many of these magic items, as that art is owned by Wizards of the Coast/Hasbro, but they need 1600 unique pieces of art (or what's the point of buying them). They then also need flavor text for those magic items that don't take up the full text box, which seems to matter most for the crafting materials cards given that they are presumably always going to have less text in them. But don't worry! They also have randomized booster packs of 15 cards of their own custom items! And you only need to buy ~50 of them to achieve 95% completion. There's also a custom card creator that works...somehow. Details are very unclear, especially on the level of how you could possibly create unique artwork for those cards and how you could print those individual cards at any reasonable cost given that they would be singletons by definition.

I started writing this section genuinely trying to give them some tiny amount of credit: it's a niche of 5E that WotC isn't currently filling, they're just using some tools I personally think are heinous to do that. But the milk of human kindness quickly curdled in my mouth when it became obvious that they're just rent-seekers of the worst variety: shamelessly profiting off of others' labor (because regardless of how you feel about D&D, the SRD is the product of actual people) while gatekeeping anything original behind a randomized lootbox, and you don't even know what those original items are like so you can't know if they're worth getting. At the end of all of this, I don't even think I believe them when they say that all final artwork will be human made because truly every single promotional image on the campaign page (including the physical products shown off in some of the promotional videos) appears to be the product of generative AI. This is just what happens when you allow this kind of slop on your platform; unless you have some intensive verification process to actually require people to prove their claims about AI usage, you'll get slop merchants essentially conning $600K+ out of the easiest marks on the planet (D&D 5E fans).

May 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026

2024 2025 2026
Campaign count
Backerkit 18 23 71
Kickstarter 133 140 118
Money Pledged
Backerkit total $735,159.58 $727,356.92 $17,186,480.54
Backerkit average $40,842.20 $31,624.21 $242,063.11
Backerkit median $8,810.00 $15,432.00 $8,237.43
Kickstarter total $7,238,839.84 $6,500,570.98 $4,076,690.03
Kickstarter average $54,427.37 $46,432.65 $34,548.22
Kickstarter median $6,766.72 $4,430.84 $4,544.00
AI
Campaign count 34 44 47
Money pledged $251,400.35 $441,459.48 $799,428.25
D&D 5E
Campaign count 59 79 81
Money pledged $4,936,605.69 $3,093,350.95 $3,837,448.45

As much as I'm tired of them, I have to say that Backerkit's Months seem to be working. May's 71 campaigns represents the high water mark for number of projects in a month on the platform, tied with February 2026 (when Zinetopia was happening). Median money pledged to campaigns has stayed relatively consistent, which means that the money isn't necessarily only flowing to the most successful campaigns too. Even with the DCCarl game raising $13M+, that's $3,888,421.54 pledged to the other 70 projects (which by itself would be the most money pledged in a month on Backerkit in 2026).

Kickstarter is having a slightly rougher time of it (but since this is coming out so far into June I can say that trend is already turning around), and has the dubious honor of hosting a $600K AI campaign. What I will say on the AI front, though, is that all ther other AI campaigns have never made so little money collectively (as when you take out that outlier you have $183,150.25 across 46 projects).

Anyways that's all. New retrospective to come in hopefully less than a month's time since this one really got away from me.

Wednesday, May 13, 2026

April 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

April sees essentially the same amount of money raised as March but with 100+ fewer successful campaigns. To find out why, take a gander at the raw data and let's dive in:

  • 152 campaigns
    • 21 Backerkit
    • 4 Gamefound
    • 127 Kickstarter
  • $10,391,851.51 raised
    • $900,727.16 on Backerkit
    • $270,258.78 on Gamefound
    • $9,220,865.57 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 16 accessories
    • 2 Actual Plays
    • 36 adventures
    • 1 advice
    • 13 campaign settings
    • 1 fundraising
    • 1 platform
    • 1 podcast
    • 42 supplements
    • 35 systems
    • 2 translations
    • 2 zines
  • 56 distinct systems used (16 original)
    • 60 campaigns (39.47%) used D&D 5E and raised $5,878,186.03 (56.57% of all money raised in April)
  • 41 campaigns used AI in some form (26.98% of total) and raised $196,777.28 (1.89% of all money raised in April)
    • 30 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 50% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 20 different countries
    • Top 3: 67 in USA, 26 in UK, 12 in Italy
    • Singleton countries: Japan, Latvia, Spain, Turkey

Backerkit's April

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in April were:

  1. Druskara: A Brutal Fantasy World Setting for Shadowdark RPG by Dungeon Damsel Publishing ($281,337.00 from 1,291 backers)
  2. ION Heart Multiplayer - A Lo-Fi Mech TTRPG by Parable Games ($175,289.77 from 1,049 backers)
  3. VHS: Very Horror Stories - Rule of Three by Aces Games ($107,867.08 from 476 backers)
  4. Imaria: Beyond the Veil by Lynnvander Studios ($66,678.00 from 444 backers)
  5. Inkvein - A MÖRK BORG Megadungeon by Space Penguin Ink LLC ($48,306.00 from 838 backers)

Backerkit might seem a bit light on the ground this month, but that's due to Megadungeon Month (which was scheduled from April 7-May 1), which would have technically 'made' most of its money in April but is going to be recorded in May's roundup. May is going to be a doozy for Backerkit, because Pocketopia and Old-School Essentials Month are running concurrently, though the latter will end in June.

Something interesting that I'm noticing is the geographic breakdown of these themed Months. 
Month % US creators
Zinetopia 2026 58.33%
Orbital Blues Month 83.33%
Megadungeon Month 88.46%
Old-School Essentials Month 88.24%
Pocketopia 2026 42.11%
Overall Backerkit (2026) 66.23%
Months themed around a particular game system heavily feature US-based creators, while those focused around getting a type of game (zines, pocket-sized games) created are more geographically diverse than the general Backerkit population. There's clearly some kind of bias entering the picture here, but whether that's a factor of where specific games tend to be popular or on Backerkit's part in selecting who gets to participate in the first place is unclear.

Gamefound's April

There were 4 campaigns on Gamefound in April:
  1. Mythic Battles: The Roleplaying Games by Monolith Board Games ($134,040.38 from 697 backers)
  2. Archmage's Gate: A Solo RPG Adventure Gamebook by Archmage Arispen ($92,967.60 from 848 backers)
  3. Fabula Ultima - Bestiarium & Deluxe-Edition by Ulisses Spiele ($42,836.81 from 217 backers)
  4. Epic Fantasy Battle Maps: 1400 Rpg Maps + 3200 Portraits by Agnesagraphic ($413.99 from 14 backers)

Gamefound is a really strange place for TTRPG projects. The most consistent projects I've seen there over the past 6 months or so are German translations of popular games and AI-driven projects (either map packs or solo games usually). Last year's RPG Party was a very mixed success, with 16 of 22 projects successfully funding. Rascal News talked to Cam Bradley. Gamefound's business manager, about what this year's RPG Party will look like, and it seems that the company is focused on two main things: projects with a physical component (a requirement) and serving as an incubator for up-and-coming talent. I have my doubts about how effective this will be overall (rooted primarily in the volatile costs of producing physical components nowadays and Bradley's shifting of blame for the failed projects from Gamefound onto the creators who displayed "an unwillingness or inability to network"), but it makes sense for them to try to carve out this niche. Kickstarter is where most people go to fund their projects, while Backerkit is leaning ever more heavily on their themed Months and the bundled shipping they are starting to provide for projects associated with said Months, so if Gamefound wants to be a serious alternative they need to find something they're particularly good at. Only time will tell if this will work.

Kickstarter's April

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in April were:
  1. Heliana & Ryoko's Guide to Mythozoology by DnD Shorts ($4,360,638.00 from 18,220 backers)
  2. When Society Collapsed: Dam Nation - A Tabletop RPG by Luke Humphris ($817,977.00 from 5,587 backers)
  3. Public Access Analog Horror Mystery TTRPG by The Gauntlet Gaming Community ($564,982.00 from 7,189 backers)
  4. Fomoria - Epic Folk Horror Roleplaying by Johan Nohr ($314,299.83 from 3,191 backers)
  5. Godzilla: The Roleplaying Game by IDW Games ($251,676.00 from 2,428 backers)

The overwhelming lesson from this April on Kickstarter is that it literally pays to have an audience/community. This is certainly not news to anyone, but just look at the top 5 from this month: DnD Shorts and Luke Humphris both have 550K+ YouTube channels, The Gauntlet is a thriving design community that also facilitates play of its own games, Johan Nohr is an indie TTRPG legend (and Tania Herrero, the other designer, is a well-known and award-winning designer herself), and Godzilla is...Godzilla.

In fact, it's notable that the hugely successful, decades-spanning IP tie-in game barely cracked the top 5. You can probably attribute that to the difficulty of turning the general Godzilla fan onto this specific TTRPG adaptation, as opposed to the other 4 projects on here, whose audiences are all specifically based in TTRPGs.

Does this mean that there is no benefit to Kickstarter as a platform? Absolutely not, you still benefit immensely from discoverability, but you can't rely on it. Don't be dependent on the platform - make them dependent on your ability to bring people in who otherwise might not come around.

April 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026

2024 2025 2026
Campaign count
Backerkit 8 51 21
Kickstarter 137 150 127
Money pledged
Backerkit total $845,617.27 $2,180,147.02 $900,727.16
Backerkit average $105,702.16 $42,747.98 $42,891.77
Backerkit median $66,034.46 $7,565.50 $10,209.76
Kickstarter total $5,683,707.15 $7,745,262.30 $9,220,865.57
Kickstarter average $41,486.91 $51,635.08 $72,605.24
Kickstarter median $5,094.00 $3,841.24 $4,716.00
AI
Campaign count 33 49 41
Money pledged $310,089.95 $213,130.42 $196,777.28
D&D 5E
Campaign count 70 82 60
Money pledged $2,486,126.48 $2,136,602.54 $5,878,186.03

As always, it's fascinating to see how outliers influence the data. For example, Kickstarter's total money raised has gone up year-over-year, but most of that growth can be attributed to just a couple of campaigns.
If you take out these top-performing campaigns you end up with the following money raised:
  • April 2024: $4,617,997.15
  • April 2025: $2,932,371.48
  • April 2026: $4,860,227.57
This is obviously not to say that the money raised on Kickstarter in April hasn't been increasing year-over-year. I'm simply pointing out how much of that increase is consistently (and increasingly) concentrated in just a few projects. I began this project because I wanted to know how much money was actually being raised in TTRPG crowdfunding, but increasingly I find it necessary to contextualize where the money is actually going since the numbers alone can't tell the whole story.

Wednesday, March 11, 2026

February 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

February is always such an interesting (or alternately for the purposes of this project: exhausting) month due to the sheer volume of projects that happen despite it being shorter than all other months. This time around is no exception! Here's the raw data, let's dig in.

  • 231 campaigns
    • 71 Backerkit
    • 1 Gamefound
    • 159 Kickstarter
  • $2,610,858.67 raised
    • $666,832.71 on Backerkit
    • $22,562.00 on Gamefound
    • $1,921,463.96 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 14 accessories
    • 2 Actual Plays
    • 53 adventures
    • 7 campaign settings
    • 2 fundraising
    • 3 LitRPGs
    • 1 platform
    • 2 reprints
    • 67 supplements
    • 75 systems
    • 1 translation
    • 4 zines
  • 119 distinct systems used (63 original)
    • 64 campaigns (27.71%) used D&D 5E and raised $1,152,107.23 (44.13% of all money raised in February)
  • 46 campaigns used AI in some form (19.91% of total) and raised $239,894.59 (9.19% of all money raised in February)
    • 28 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 43.75% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 21 different countries
    • Top 3: 122 in USA, 30 in UK, 17 in Italy
    • Singleton countries: Austria, Cyprus, Ireland, Mexico, Portugal, Switzerland

Backerkit's February

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in February were:
  1. Old-School Adventures & Pinball Crawl Classics! by Goodman Games ($187,677 from 2,063 backers)
  2. Bloodpunk: Night Before the White Wake - Adventure and VTT by DRS Publishing ($73,215.22 from 543 backers)
  3. Level Up: A5E Gate Pass Gazette Annual 2025 by EN Publishing ($29,086.04 from 468 backers)
  4. Triple-O: the player character emulator by Cezar Capacle ($26,234.92 from 1,005 backers)
  5. DedBoi - an investigative solo TTRPG by Critical Kit Ltd ($24,113.43 from 657 backers)

Gamefound's February

There was one campaign on Gamefound in February: Astromythos by jsideriadis ($22,562 from 193 backers)

Kickstarter's February

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in February were:

  1. Eternal Ruins: The Roleplaying Game by Mythworks ($295,166 from 3,208 backers)
  2. Night Hunters: Gothic Horror for TOV and 5E D&D by Kobold Press ($223,878 from 1,934 backers)
  3. Dungeon, Inc. by Olivier Revenu ($149,746 from 2,583 backers)
  4. Tainted Grail TTRPG: Life and Death in Avalon by Jim Searcy ($103,710 from 940 backers)
  5. REALM: The Soul Searchers Protocol by Jonathan Matteson ($102,420 from 2,583 backers)

February 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026

2024 2025 2026
Campaign count
Backerkit 12 19 71
Kickstarter 214 202 159
Money pledged
Backerkit total $884,266.93 $1,194,103.59 $666,832.71
Backerkit average $73,688.91 $62,847.56 $9,392.01
Backerkit median $6,662.59 $7,653.65 $4,233.00
Kickstarter total $2,468,976.14 $2,936,765.97 $1,921,463.96
Kickstarter average $11,537.27 $14,538.45 $12,084.68
Kickstarter median $3,768.33 $3,116.00 $3,483.00
AI
Campaign count 35 39 46
Money pledged $236,973.58 $197,675.97 $239,894.59
D&D 5E
Campaign count 57 58 64
Money pledged $592,773.60 $1,773,005.23 $1,152,107.23

We are gathered here today to honor the memories of ZineQuest/ZineMonth/ZineTopia -- not because they're dead but because they might as well be in many regards. Let me be clear: I am not saying they're bad initiatives or that they shouldn't happen again. But we should all be honest with ourselves that they just don't really mean much anymore from even a marketing perspective.

I've said previously that I don't want to get too hung up on the money raised by crowdfunding projects as the sole, or even primary, metric of success, and that remains true. But I can't ignore that by that metric, this year's zine-themed initiatives have fared considerably worse thus far than those of previous years. ZineTopia, Backerkit's official foray into the zine space, more than tripled the number of successful projects (an unalloyed good!) yet raised the least money in February since 2024. When I talked about ZineTopia and general month fatigue back in October 2025, I was primarily concerned that Backerkit was going to become a gatekeeper obstructing people's participation in their February initiative, which I am glad to say hasn't happened. But the result has highlighted the platform's seeming dependence on high-profile campaigns from established creators. By and large, it seems that larger creators genuinely respected the ZineTopia initiative (or that Backerkit was enforcing its primacy behind the scenes) and yet that initiative was responsible for just over 50% ($343,710.45 by my data, $357,613 by the official page) of Backerkit's February total. The rest? That came mostly from the top 3 campaigns I listed above (all of which began before ZineTopia started). Even Kickstarter saw a dip in February metrics despite the continued presence of successful campaigns from indies like Mythworks and established companies like Kobold Press, suggesting that even the most successful campaigns are suffering from a general malaise. I can't say whether this is due to crowdfunding oversaturation, worsening economies the world over (but especially the US), some secret third thing, or a combination therein (the most likely answer I'd say).

So what are we to do with all this? It's really difficult to say. I really appreciate that ZineMonth is a community-organized initiative that lives outside of a crowdfunding platform, but it just doesn't have much of an ability to break outside of the existing indie TTRPG field. ZineQuest doesn't seem to be giving the same benefits it once did, and ZineTopia is a troubling indicator of future success (or lack thereof) of themed Months for Backerkit. The main hopeful statistic I can see in this is that the median campaign still raises ~$3K-$4K whether it's on Backerkit or Kickstarter (the median across all February campaigns was $3,868.00), and this has been stable for a number of months, if not years. Yes, the February median fell by quite a bit year-over-year for Backerkit, but that's just reflective of more, smaller projects getting on the platform. Crowdfunding campaigns just have to get increasingly realistic: there's no real evidence of a rising tide that's lifting all ships, but there is at least a consistent water level that should hopefully keep you from getting stranded on the rocks.

Friday, February 6, 2026

January 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

2026 is off to kind of a strange start, in ways both good and bad. Good: solid funding numbers, solid numbers of campaigns. Bad: AI slop, removing Crowdfundr from examination (it hasn't had an actual campaign in months). Check out the raw data if you want, and let's dive in.

  • 90 campaigns
    • 10 Backerkit
    • 1 Gamefound
    • 79 Kickstarter
  • $4,019,799.97 raised
    • $2,956,743.28 on Backerkit
    • $28,448.46 on Gamefound
    • $1,034,608.23 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 15 accessories
    • 22 adventures
    • 1 audiobook
    • 1 campaign setting
    • 2 reprints
    • 33 supplements
    • 14 systems
    • 1 translation
    • 1 zine
  • 26 distinct systems used (8 original)
    • 38 campaigns (42.22%) used D&D 5E and raised $657,446.68 (16.36% of all money raised in January)
  • 41 campaigns used AI in some form (45.56% of total) and raised $225,000.64 (5.60% of all money raised in January)
    • 23 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 60.53% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 13 different countries
    • Top 3: 42 in USA, 19 in UK, 5 in each of Canada, Italy, and the Netherlands
    • Singleton countries: Denmark, France, Norway, Spain, Vietnam

Backerkit's January

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in January were:
  1. Draw Steel: Crack the Sun by MCDM Productions ($2,617,323 from 9,590 backers)
  2. Toon the Cartoon Roleplaying Game Second Edition by Steve Jackson Games ($142,690 from 3,181 backers)
  3. Ultimate Toolbox by World's Largest RPGs ($90,475 from 837 backers)
  4. Somnus Domina 2025 : Three 5th Edition Splash Books by Nat19 ($55,163.69 from 520 backers)
  5. Crush Your Game Nights! AtR goes VTT on Roll20 by Rusted Portal Games ($20,867 from 14 backers)

Gamefound's January

There was only 1 campaign on Gamefound in January: Cthulhu 2050: Whispers Beyond The Stars by OtherWorlds ($28,448.46 from 653 backers)

Kickstarter's January

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in January were:
  1. The Thundercats Roleplaying Game is Here! by Dynamite Toys & Games ($307,397 from 2,517 backers)
  2. The Wyrmwood Modular Gaming Table: NOW ADJUSTABLE⬆🤯⬇ by Wyrmwood Gaming ($162,066 from 803 backers)
  3. 2D6 Void - A Classic Sci-fi Dungeon Crawler - Solo Play by Toby Lancaster ($91,687.10 from 1,241 backers)
  4. Enchanted Trinkets Complete: 500+ Magic Items for D&D 5E by Morrus ($38,470.85 from 729 backers)
  5. Arathi Sector by Castle Grief ($35,882 from 683 backers)

January 2024 vs 2025 vs 2026


2024 2025 2026
Campaign count
Backerkit 4 6 10
Kickstarter 71 62 79
Money pledged
Backerkit total $4,608,855.66 $199,232.66 $2,956,743.28
Backerkit average $1,152,213.92 $33,205.44 $295,674.33
Backerkit median $3,777.61 $3,231.00 $18,863.55
Kickstarter total $801,189.61 $354,795.72 $1,034,608.23
Kickstarter average $11,284.36 $5,722.51 $13,096.31
Kickstarter median $4,045.68 $3,294.00 $3,438.50
AI
Campaign count 19 28 41
Money pledged $113,268.66 $130,553.04 $225,000.64
D&D 5E
Campaign count 32 37 38
Money pledged $367,344.91 $176,170.54 $657,446.68

January 2026 was an unexpectedly strong showing for both Backerkit and Kickstarter compared to the frankly abysmal numbers from January 2025. Backerkit's success was primarily (but not entirely) fueled by another strong showing from the MCDM team with their first major follow-up to Draw Steel, as the other 9 January 2026 Backerkit campaigns collectively raised more than last year's total ($339,420.28 sans MCDM's campaign).

Kickstarter also saw their strongest January in years, topping even 2024 in both money raised and number of successful campaigns. Unfortunately, January 2026 was the first time when campaigns using AI accounted for more than 50% of the successful TTRPG campaigns on the platform. 41 projects using AI isn't anywhere near a high water mark within a given month, but  51.9% of successful projects is the highest I've seen so far. Money-wise, AI campaigns also raised more than the past 2 years in raw amount, but only accounted for 21.75% of Kickstarter money raised.

This made me think: does anything in particular explain/predict how successful AI campaigns will be on the whole? I looked at a couple of different predictor variables (number of AI campaigns, number of non-AI campaigns, number of total campaigns, total money raised) and largely came up blank. There's no evidence to suggest, for example, that a rising tide (overall money raised) lifts all ships equally. But if you look at the relationship between the percentage of AI campaigns and the percentage of money raised by AI campaigns, something emerges.

Graph showing a very slightly positive relationship between the % of AI campaigns and the % of AI money raised
Slight positive relationship between % of AI Kickstarter campaigns and % of AI Kickstarter money raised
(y = 0.5436x - 0.0686, R2 = 0.3507)

Yes, you're seeing that right: there is a very weak association that AI does better when it occupies more of the market on Kickstarter.
 This equation explains very little of the variance (only ~35% in fact), but it agrees with what feels true to me: the slop produced by AI can only really compete with real creativity if it is collectively flooding the zone with shit. When everything looks too smooth and shiny, it's easier to ignore it and just accept it as the norm.

Now I'm the first to admit that this is not a strong result. Any statistician will tell you that this R2 is, in fact, dogshit and that you can't draw meaningful conclusions from it. Based on these data, AI is far more likely to underperform than anything else, given that ~2/3 of the data points fall beneath the trendline. If there is any particular silver lining to be taken from all this, it's that the presence of AI campaigns seems to overall be independent of the money going to real artists. I have yet to find evidence that it's a zero-sum game, so I wouldn't stress too much over whether there's a bunch of AI campaigns already in the field or not.

Saturday, January 3, 2026

December 2025 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

 Mashup of Backerkit, Gamefound, and Kickstarter logos reading: BACKfoundER

Another year gone, and a rather strange December for TTRPG crowdfunding closes it out. Here's the raw data; let's dive in.

  • 178 campaigns
    • 63 Backerkit
    • 0 Crowdfundr
    • 2 Gamefound
    • 113 Kickstarter
  • $4,021,004.70 raised
    • $1,712,583.76 on Backerkit
    • $0.00 on Crowdfundr
    • $20,154.16 on Gamefound
    • $2,288,266.78 on Kickstarter
  • Types of campaigns
    • 11 accessories
    • 43 adventures
    • 9 campaign settings
    • 28 Holiday Markets
    • 1 magazine
    • 1 platform
    • 1 podcast
    • 3 reprints
    • 50 supplements
    • 29 systems
    • 1 translation
    • 1 zine
  • 60 distinct systems used (14 original)
    • 68 campaigns (38.20%) used D&D 5E and raised $795,500.44 (19.78% of all money raised in December)
  • 38 campaigns used AI in some form (21.35% of total) and raised $125,773.25 (3.13% of all money raised in December)
    • 25 of these were D&D 5E campaigns, accounting for 36.76% of all 5E crowdfunding campaigns
  • Campaigns were based in 17 different countries
    • Top 3: 89 in USA, 30 in UK, 11 in Canada
    • Singleton countries: Japan, New Zealand, Portugal, Singapore

Backerkit's December

The top 5 campaigns on Backerkit in December were:
  1. Twilight Sword by Two Little Mice ($822,492.30 from 5,189 backers)
  2. Infernals: Crowned by Hellfire for the Exalted 3E RPG by Onyx Path ($191,285 from 2,126 backers)
  3. Mausritter Junk City by Exalted Funeral Press, Games Omnivorous, and Losing Games ($168,735 from 1,956 backers)
  4. DCC+5E Crowdfunding Exclusives & Mystery Gifts! by Goodman Games ($66,155 from 570 backers)
  5. Loot Tavern Lighting Sale by Loot Tavern Publishing ($46,756 from 355 backers)

Gamefound's December

The 2 campaigns on Gamefound in December were:
  1. Vileborn - Das düster-heroische Rollenspiel by Ulisses Spiele ($19,874.72 from 208 backers)
  2. 1130+ Fantasy Battle maps for TTRPG and VTTRPG by Agnesagraphic ($279.44 from 7 backers)

Kickstarter's December

The top 5 campaigns on Kickstarter in December were:
  1. Life After Everything: Astro Oceans 🌊 Tarot Tabletop RPG by Gifted Ocean ($363,871 from 2,418 backers)
  2. Fighting Fantasy - Solo Adventure Gamebooks - Set 2 by Steve Jackson Games ($278,223 from 3,977 backers)
  3. Apocalypse World: Burned Over by Vincent Baker ($215,104 from 3,763 backers)
  4. The Dungeon Reignited. Set of 2 Book of Battle Mats for RPG by Loke Battle Maps ($168,212 from 1,569 backers)
  5. Tome of Mystical Tattoos III for D&D 5e by Karl Nicolas ($152,837.86 from 1,810 backers)

December 2023 vs 2024 vs 2025

2023 2024 2025
Campaign count
Backerkit 7 35 63
Kickstarter 112 130 113
Money pledged
Backerkit total $116,631.00 $1,898,104.11 $1,712,583.76
Backerkit average $16,661.57 $54,231.55 $27,183.87
Backerkit median $8,599.00 $13,703.65 $5,091.89
Kickstarter total $3,062,243.35 $2,213,471.01 $2,288,266.78
Kickstarter average $27,341.46 $17,026.70 $20,250.15
Kickstarter median $4,507.04 $3,266.92 $3,602.00
AI
Campaign count 32 37 38
Money pledged $150,217.33 $145,101.71 $125,773.25
D&D 5E
Campaign count 48 73 68
Money pledged $999,475.20 $917,977.49 $795,500.44

Backerkit has come a long way since December 2023, but it's really interesting to compare its Dec 2024 vs Dec 2025 considering that both Mausritter Month and their Holiday Market happened in 2025. Let's break down the stats of both:
  • Mausritter Month
    • $323,197.86 pledged (18.87% of money pledged on Backerkit in December)
    • 16 projects (all successfully funded)
    • $20,199.87 average
    • $9,570.55 median
  • Holiday Market (TTRPGs only and limited to projects actually providing something gameable and not just merch)
    • $261,890.54 pledged (15.29% of money pledged on Backerkit in December)
    • 28 projects (no funding goals)
    • $9,353.23 average
    • $3,255.65 median
Mausritter Month was clearly a success by any metric (all projects funded, pretty good average, really high median), but it notably raised less money from fewer projects than either Mothership Month. Not only that, but you would think that these kinds of initiatives would boost the overall money pledged on Backerkit, but instead there was a slight decrease from 2024 to 2025. It is definitely too early to say that backers are experiencing Month fatigue the same way I am, but these numbers might explain why Backerkit is ramping up their promotional events: they need them to boost otherwise flagging traffic.

I'm going to be getting into it in a 2025 wrap-up post, but this year was not great money-wise for TTRPG crowdfunding. There are more projects than ever and less money to go around, and nothing from the past 6 months suggests that's going to change anytime soon. These promotional events from Backerkit are relatively easy ways to get users on their platform, entice creators to put their campaigns there, and the money that comes from it will keep the floor from falling out of their bottom line. Obviously I can't speak to how healthy their other types of campaigns look, but I can't imagine they're looking all that much better than TTRPGs right now. A combination of US economic uncertainty and tariffs playing havoc with both international shipping and component production is going to make everyone just feel less than great about putting money down on something that isn't a sure bet.

Which brings me to the Holiday Market. I personally don't like it. It makes complete sense for Backerkit and the creators involved, but any move by a crowdfunding platform towards becoming a sales platform just doesn't make me feel good. Especially because the whole premise was that anything you 'back' will ship within just a few weeks and (theoretically) arrive in time for Christmas. So these aren't even campaigns for reprints! It's just a promotional 'preorder' event, even more so than many 'crowdfunding' campaigns are these days! Again, makes complete sense for creators to participate since it's an easy way to sell some extra inventory you might have lying around, but that just seems like something that doesn't belong on a crowdfunding platform.

There's not really a bigger conclusion to draw from this in the end, at least not yet. My brain is pretty goopy just from general post-holiday post-New-Year post-travel stuff, so I'm really saving up anything particularly relevant for the full year review coming sometime soon.

June 2026 TTRPG Crowdfunding Retrospective

It's still July, so this isn't yet completely 100% late. That's a win in my book, so check out the raw data and dive in. June 2...